National Transmission Analysis Maps Next Chapter of US Grid Evolution
Content
Indicated PJM TOs Rehearing Request at 7, 23-27; SPP TOs Rehearing Request at 7-8, 21-28. Of State Univ. of N.Y., 492 U.S. 469; see supra Requirements Concerning Relevant State Entities' Agreed-upon Cost Allocation Methods section. See supra Requirements Concerning Relevant State Entities' Agreed-upon Cost Allocation Methods section. See 16 U.S.C. 824d(c) (providing that “every public utility shall file with the Commission . . . schedules showing all rates and charges for any transmission or sale subject to the jurisdiction of the Commission, and the classifications, practices, and regulations affecting such rates and charges”). Order No. 1920-A, 189 FERC ¶ 61,126 at P 691 n.1747 (“We clarify that this consultation requirement neither requires transmission providers to submit, nor prohibits transmission providers from submitting, FPA section 205 filings to modify cost allocation methods accepted in compliance with Order No. 1920, and transmission providers therefore retain their currently effective FPA section 205 rights.”).
The report, Barriers and Opportunities to Realize the System Value of Interregional Transmission, groups barriers and opportunities for interregional transmission among all regions, between non-market or a mix of market and non-market areas, and between market areas. NLR examined issues that prevent existing transmission facilities from delivering maximum potential value and developed a suite of options that power system stakeholders can pursue to overcome those challenges. A challenging but crucial part of realizing the benefits of transmission expansion is adopting unprecedented planning approaches that can accommodate the energy needs for diverse regions at differing scales. The study team performed nodal analysis of U.S. transmission expansion scenarios, providing valuable insights into potential challenges that could arise as planners and operators manage large-scale transitions.
- The Commission clarifies that it will be the transmission provider's decision as to whether to file an LTRTF Cost Allocation Method(s) and/or State Agreement Process to which Relevant State Entities have agreed.
- As part of the NTP Study, NLR and Pacific Northwest National Laboratory conducted a qualitative assessment of obstacles to interregional transmission, a high-level survey of potential opportunities to overcome those challenges, and which system actors or organizations are best equipped to lead each solution.
- The State Agreement Process is defined as “a process by which one or more Relevant State Entities may voluntarily agree to a cost allocation method for Long-Term Regional Transmission Facilities (or a portfolio of such Facilities) either before or no later than six months after the facilities are selected in the regional transmission plan for purposes of cost allocation.”
- The Final Rule requires transmission providers in each transmission planning region to file one or more ex ante cost allocation methods that apply to selected LTRTFs.
- NLR also identified transformative actions that could be applied to all regions to increase the value of interregional transmission.
Indicated PJM TOs Rehearing Request at (citing Entergy, 40 F.4th ); SPP TOs Rehearing Request at n.49 (same); see Order No. 1920-A, 189 FERC ¶ 61,126 at P 658 & n.1656. Indicated PJM TOs Rehearing Request at (citing 16 U.S.C. 824d; Atlantic City I, 295 F.2d at 9-11; Massachusetts Department of Public Utilities, 729 F.2d at 888). Order No. 1920-A, 189 FERC ¶ 61,126 at PP 651, 655; infra Requirements Concerning Relevant State Entities' Agreed-upon Cost Allocation Methods section. For purposes of Order No. 1920, Long-Term Transmission Needs are transmission needs identified through Long-Term Regional Transmission Planning by, among other things and as discussed in Order Nos. 1920 and 1920-A, running scenarios and considering the enumerated categories of factors. We also reiterate that Order No. 1920 allows other participants, including the municipal electric regulatory bodies and non-public utility entities mentioned above that do not otherwise meet the definition of a Relevant State Entity, to participate in a State Agreement Process, if https://kajisoku.net/how-to-achieve-maximum-success-with-5/ agreed to by Relevant State Entities. As discussed in greater detail above, the court in Atlantic City I was not addressing a Commission regulation akin to the regulation of transmission providers' consultation practices relating to cost allocation for Long-Term Regional Transmission Facilities.
Access this book
FERC regulates public utility transmission providers to ensure rates are “just and reasonable” and practices, including access to transmission services, do not discriminate or give preference to certain actors. These tools include modeling and simulating market rules, developing computational methods, and performing real-time analysis of market behavior and its impact on market performance. See also Indicated PJM TOs Rehearing Request at 5 (“ Order No. 1920-A fails to make the finding required by the first prong and to establish a replacement rate under the second prong.” (emphasis added)). See Indicated PJM TOs Rehearing Request at 24 nn.89-91, 25 n.94; SPP TOs Rehearing Request at nn.58-60, n.67, nn.71-73, 26 nn.75-76, 27 nn.80-82. Indicated PJM TOs Rehearing Request at 23-27; SPP TOs Rehearing Request at 21-28.
See Indicated PJM TOs Rehearing Request at (arguing that Order No. 1920-A “compels speech in violation of the First Amendment” and “violates First Amendment petitioning rights”). SPP TOs Rehearing Request at (arguing that requiring a transmission provider to include Relevant State Entities' information with its own commandeers the transmission provider's compliance filing, citing PG&E, 475 U.S. 1). MISO TOs Rehearing Request at (arguing that the “most reasonable way to interpret the rule is that the Commission is empowering states with such new `authority,' permitting Relevant State Entities to dictate transmission cost allocation, critically, over the objection of the filing utility itself”). See supra Requirements Concerning Relevant State Entities' Agreed-upon Cost Allocation Methods, Statutory Filing Rights Under the FPA section. Indicated PJM TOs Rehearing Request at 8 (citing Mayor of Balt. v. Azar, 973 F.3d 258, 275 (4th Cir. 2020) (other citations omitted)); MISO TOs Rehearing Request at (citing 5 U.S.C. 706 (other citations omitted)); SPP TOs Rehearing Request at 2 (citing 5 U.S.C. 706(2)).
See, e.g., MISO TOs Rehearing Request at 27-28; EEI Rehearing Request at 13-14; WIRES Rehearing Request at 7-8; SPP TOs Rehearing Request at 11 (also asserting that this approach contravenes Massachusetts Department of Public Utilities, 729 F.2d at 888). The Commission clarified that this consultation requirement neither requires transmission providers to submit, nor prohibits transmission providers from submitting, FPA section 205 filings to modify cost allocation methods accepted in compliance with Order No. 1920, and transmission providers therefore retain their currently effective FPA section 205 rights. Svcs., 61 FERC at 62, (1992) (“A compliance filing is not a change initiated by a utility, but rather is a change expressly directed by the Commission . . . which the utility is merely implementing or carrying out.”); id. at 62,330 (“A public utility submits compliance filings in response to Commission directives. The Commission issues these directives under its authority to fix a rate by order.”).
- See id. at (noting that, under Order No. 1920, filing a Relevant State Entity's proposed Long-Term Regional Transmission Cost Allocation Method was voluntary).
- See MISO TOs Rehearing Request at 5 (“These changes reframe the roles of the entities involved, blurring the FPA's division of authority.”); Indicated PJM TOs Rehearing Request at 7, 15-17; SPP TOs Rehearing Request at 2, 7, 10-11.
- Order No. 1920-A, 189 FERC ¶ 61,126 at P 692 (“We find that these requirements will ensure that states have the opportunity to be involved in establishing cost allocation methods for Long-Term Regional Transmission Facilities subsequent to the Commission's acceptance of transmission providers' filings made in compliance with Order No. 1920.”).
- WIRES here challenges both the compliance filing requirements, discussed above, and certain consultation requirements set forth by Order No. 1920-A, see infra Consultation with Relevant State Entities After the Engagement Period section, as arbitrary and capricious for the same reasons.
- The consultation requirement does not allow Relevant State Entities to compel a transmission provider to change or not change its cost allocation method.
- Further, we emphasize that nothing in Order No. 1920 or Order No. 1920-A prevents transmission providers generally from consulting or working closely with stakeholders in addition to Relevant State Entities to ensure the success of Long-Term Regional Transmission Planning.
- For purposes of Order No. 1920, a State Agreement Process is a process by which one or more Relevant State Entities may voluntarily agree to a cost allocation method for Long-Term Regional Transmission Facilities (or a portfolio of such Facilities) before or no later than six months after they are selected in the regional transmission plan for purposes of cost allocation.
- Ex ante cost allocation.” Order No. 1920-A's consultation requirement, similarly, aims to ensure the development and application of cost allocation methods that will themselves facilitate the timely, efficient development of Long-Term Regional Transmission Facilities, through states' critical role in that process.
- See also EEI Rehearing Request at 6-8 (arguing that this requires utilities to file cost allocation methods they are opposed to and that the Commission did not identify text in the FPA authorizing this approach); WIRES Rehearing Request at 2, 15 (same).
- For purposes of Order No. 1920, a Long-Term Regional Transmission Cost Allocation Method is an ex ante regional cost allocation method for one or more Long-Term Regional Transmission Facilities (or a portfolio of such Facilities) that are selected in the regional transmission plan for purposes of cost allocation.
See Indicated PJM https://miamicottages.com/what-is-a-debt-collector-and-why-are-they-contacting-me.html TOs Rehearing Request at 22-23; SPP TOs Rehearing Request at n.49. Indicated PJM TOs Rehearing Request at 6-7 (emphasis added); see also id. at 2-3; id. at 14 (citing Atlantic City I, which addressed FPA section 205 rights, and referring to the “passive” role of the Commission, which pertains under FPA section 205). As discussed below, Order No. 1920-A's approach to considering compliance filings on cost allocation represents a limited departure, in these particular circumstances, from the Commission's typical approach of adopting public utilities' proposals in compliance filings if they are compliant with the requirements of the final rule.
Release of National Transmission Planning Study Shifts Energy Transition Into High
They assert that this preference is justified (as recognized by Commission precedent) because public utilities have the primary https://exprimamedia.com/essential-tips-for-lifestyle-cost-planning-today.html initiative to set their rates, terms, and conditions of service and because, should the Commission adopt a compliance proposal from an entity other than the public utility, the public utility could immediately refile its own proposal under FPA section 205. FPA section 205 requires that the public utility, subject to Commission oversight, “file with the Commission . MISO TOs assert that the Commission's explanation that a Relevant State Entity's proposed method or process does not constitute a “proposal” is an “empty formalism with no grounding in the statutory text” that does not change the impact of the requirement on transmission providers' FPA section 205 filing rights. In Order No. 1920-A, the Commission noted that, when acting under FPA section 206, the Commission's statutory burden is to “establish a just and reasonable and not unduly discriminatory replacement rate that is supported by substantial evidence.” The Commission further noted that the statute does not necessarily require the Commission to adopt the transmission provider's proposal on compliance, even if that proposal complies with the final rule's requirements. WestConnect CTOs assert that the ban on use of a coordinating transmission owner framework would all but ensure the failure of regional transmission planning in WestConnect, contrary to the objectives of Order Nos. 1000 and 1920. WestConnect CTOs state that while the Commission found in its order on remand from El Paso that WestConnect remains an integrated transmission planning region even without participation of coordinating transmission owners, the Commission does not incorporate or reference that finding in Order No. 1920-A.
Current Trends and Challenges in Sustainable Generation, Transmission and Distribution of Electricity
The Final Rule requires transmission providers in each transmission planning region to file one or more ex ante cost allocation methods that apply to selected LTRTFs. As part of the NTP Study, NLR and Pacific Northwest National Laboratory conducted a qualitative assessment of obstacles to interregional transmission, a high-level survey of potential opportunities to overcome those challenges, and which system actors or organizations are best equipped to lead each solution. NLR also identified transformative actions that could be applied to all regions to increase the value of interregional transmission.
Key Findings of the Needs Study
Ex ante cost allocation.” Order No. 1920-A's consultation requirement, similarly, aims to ensure the development and application of cost allocation methods that will themselves facilitate the timely, efficient development of Long-Term Regional Transmission Facilities, through states' critical role in that process. GDO's Transmission Division evaluates national transmission needs, works to develop new and updated tools for transmission modeling, analysis and planning efforts, and implements DOE policies and programs to provide commercial facilitation support to advance transmission deployment. The State Agreement Process is defined as “a process by which one or more Relevant State Entities may voluntarily agree to a cost allocation method for Long-Term Regional Transmission Facilities (or a portfolio of such Facilities) either before or no later than six months after the facilities are selected in the regional transmission plan for purposes of cost allocation.” The Commission clarifies that it will be the transmission provider's decision as to whether to file an LTRTF Cost Allocation Method(s) and/or State Agreement Process to which Relevant State Entities have agreed.